Pierre, there’s butter in my brioche


I had to laugh when I saw Pierre Hermé’s brioche recipe described as “richer than Bill Gates!” The archetypal French viennoiserie, compared to an all-American capitaliste?

Then, a few days ago, I read that Bill Gates is once again the richest man in the world, taking back the title from Mexico’s Carlos Slim. Such is the world of impossible riches (72 billions, really??), shady dealings and fickle finance.

If I were Bill Gates, I’d be celebrating with a bottle of the best champagne, and a few slices of baguette liberally smeared with smelly French cheese and garnished with truffles. Whole truffles. Make that the biggest truffles, just like Alice B Toklas wrote. Then, I’d spend time learning to make the perfect brioche.

I guess that’s why I will never be rich like Bill Gates or Carlos Slim. They love making money and owning Microsoft / America Movi. I like baking, and reading books for hours on end. And learning to make brioche.


This “richer than Bill Gates” recipe is the closest I’ll get to feeling like a multi-billionaire. There is a whopping amount of butter, as much butter as there is of flour. “Enriched” doesn’t begin to describe what happens to the dough, ‘supersized by butter’ is closer to the mark.

Yet, such is the miracle of brioche, what came out of the oven wasn’t stodgy, or greasy, or heavy. Although the bread was richer than any bread I’ve ever had, although we knew we were eating butter by the spoonful, the bread was light, with an open, tender crumb, almost fluffy. There was a flaky crust that shattered – but oh so delicately – when we bite into it. Then there’s the ‘chiffon cake-like crumb’, as TX Farmer from the Fresh Loaf describes.

Deceptively light and easy to eat.

My brioche dough was very soft, probably because I accidentally added too much beaten eggs. Even though it didn’t hold its shape well, taste-wise, it was still one of the more exciting things to come out of the oven. 

The recipe gave us so much brioche dough, so I played with the shape of the dough, and (by necessity) different baking utensils. There was a ring-shaped brioche, made in a bundt cake pan; there were the mini cupcake-sized round; balls of brioche dough that filled a quarter-sized ceramic tart pan with a flower pattern, and were topped with sugar and more (!) butter for a caramel crust; and finally – maybe my favourite – brioche dough that was laced with quince jam and baked in fluted mini-tart pans.

And how can anyone not feel richer than Bill Gates with a mountain of freshly baked, super-enriched brioche in the house?


I read a number of brioche tutorials before I started this, and here’s a round-up of tips that I found useful:

  • not all brioche recipes are made equal. In some recipes, the weight of butter is less than 80% of the weight of flour, apparently these are poorman’s (impoverished proletariats? petite bourgeoisie?) brioche doughs. In other recipes, the weight of butter is more than 80% of the weight of flour, and these are rich (l’aristocrate?) brioche dough. By this measure, Pierre Hermé’s recipe has an equal weight of butter and flour, and is brioche fit for Le Roi.
  • make sure everything is at room temperature, particularly the butter. The butter should be soft (but not melted), so that it mixes more easily into the dough. An earlier attempt at enriched dough left me with flecks of cold butter in the dough, not the end of the world but not the best.
  • if you are using instant or dried yeast (like me), use lukewarm milk to make sure the yeast gets to the frothing stage.
  • a few recipes emphasise kneading the dough for a long time, to properly develop the long gluten strands, before adding the butter. The idea is the gluten will have to be strong enough to lift up the butter-laden dough. I guess this is more important for a ‘richer’ or more aristocratic brioche dough.
  • on the point of proper kneading, a number of recipes will tell you that you can’t make brioche dough by hand. Bof, I say. The French chef made brioche long before we had KitchenAid, and Dorie Greenspan said she learned to make brioche the hard way, with a bowl and spoon and plenty of elbow grease. Having said that, kneading brioche dough is hard work. If you have a heavy duty mixer, use it – and keep watching to make sure it doesn’t overheat.
  • some recipes tell you to rest the dough for at least a few hours in the fridge, others suggest overnight. I’ve found resting overnight gives the dough a chance to rise, slowly, leisurely, and get those lovely long strands of gluten. So, even if it’s not necessary, I’m a fan of the overnight rest.

And, that’s about it.

As for eating, general consensus is that brioche is at its stunning best just cooled from the oven. They were beautiful to eat within a day of baking, still quite good within two days. By day three, I was thinking of French toast (or coupétade, or bettelman). I froze some of the remaining brioche for projects like apple bread and butter pudding. Who said a mountain of brioche is excessive? 


100% butter brioche, from Pierre Hermé

(from the Fresh Loaf)


Bread flour, 300g
Sugar, 39g (I used castor or granulated sugar)
dried yeast, 4.8g (I measured just over 6% of instant yeast)
salt, 8.4g (I measured just about 10g of coarse rock salt)
egg, 210g (three eggs came to about 240g, and I tipped all of the beaten eggs into the mixture by accident. The dough survived, but was very soft)
butter, 300g, softened and at room temperature (I used cultured European butter)


1. The first day: mix flour, sugar, yeast, salt, and half of eggs together with dough hook until it cleans the bowl.

2. Add the rest of eggs, mix until clean the bowl. It took me about 15 minutes, mixer on second lowest setting, and stopping to scrape down the bowl every now and then. The gluten must be strong before adding butter.

3. Cube butter. Add butter a little at a time, mix well each time. The idea is to mix the dough with a dough hook until the dough wraps around the hook and cleans the bowl. TX Farmer got the dough to the ‘window pane’ stage (i.e. you can stretch the dough so thin, you can see light coming through the membrane-like dough). Mine got to window pane, just.

4. Rise at room temp until double (this took more than two hours for me!). Punch the dough down, cover and put in fridge for 2 hours. Punch the dough down again, cover and put back in fridge for at least 4 hours or overnight.

5. The next day: divide and shape the dough right out of fridge, when it is cold and managable. This dough does expand a lot, so don’t over-fill your baking pans or moulds.

6. Proof at room temperature until the dough more than doubles in size. This took just over 3 hours for me.

7. Brush with Egg wash, or, dollop on quince jam, or, sprinkle sugar and butter on top of the dough for a mild caramel crunch. Bake the small tart pans at 420F / 215C for 10min, then at 375F / 190C for about 15min. The cupcake-sized mini rolls took about 10 minutes at 375F / 190C.

Pierre, I want some more…

Here are some brioche tutorials or alternative recipes I’ve bookmarked along the way:


Tagged: , , , , , , , , , ,

24 thoughts on “Pierre, there’s butter in my brioche

  1. merrymennonite 2 June 2013 at 4:30 am Reply

    My goodness I might have to try this. I’m not usually much of a one for fancy foods, but anything made with that much butter I need to try.

  2. Experienced Tutors 2 June 2013 at 4:57 am Reply

    Strange how your posts always make me feel hungry. 🙂

    • saucygander 2 June 2013 at 9:13 am Reply

      With all that butter, you won’t be hungry for long! 😉

  3. tinywhitecottage 2 June 2013 at 10:42 am Reply

    It is always a delight to see your posts. Beautifully presented, written and photographed. Very inspirational.

    • saucygander 2 June 2013 at 11:55 pm Reply

      Thanks you so much! This is what I absolutely love doing, and I’m glad this blog allows me to share and “meet” other people. 🙂

  4. johnnysenough hepburn 2 June 2013 at 12:34 pm Reply

    I do like brioche, although I haven’t had it in years. Got to ask, what is the difference in the bread flour as opposed to plain flour? As you’re probably aware I’ve only started baking again recently. Not that I did much before.

    • saucygander 2 June 2013 at 11:59 pm Reply

      Bread or strong flour is higher in gluten, which makes the dough rise more easily and have more strength/structure. But, I’ve seen heaps of bloggers who create marvellous looking bread with only plain / AP flour, probably with more kneading or longer rising times. I guess using bread flour is like taking a shortcut.

      • johnnysenough hepburn 3 June 2013 at 12:10 am

        Thanks for that. It’s called strong plain flour over here, which I already have in stock 🙂

  5. mydearbakes 2 June 2013 at 4:24 pm Reply

    What a marvelous looking bake! Yummy! =)

  6. ebbaluring 3 June 2013 at 12:37 am Reply

    Ohh wow! I just loved this, you write in a lovely way.. and then a subject about brioche.. Yummie!

  7. prettyeasylife 3 June 2013 at 1:48 am Reply

    Brioches are my favorite thing in life, love them so bad I can not even dare to bake them. But one day, as a treat, I will use your recipe. Thanks for the detailed instructions.

  8. yummychunklet 3 June 2013 at 12:59 pm Reply

    These look delectable!

  9. Silphium - Jane Levi on food 3 June 2013 at 7:43 pm Reply

    How gorgeous! Thanks for stopping into my blog and letting me find out about yours.
    It’s great to see your magnificent brioche. I’m recently back from Paris where the incredible Lyonnais chocolatier Pralus has a shop where he also bakes his amazing brioche. It’s hugely, disgracefully buttery, and studded with rose pralinated almonds. Talk about gilding the lily!

  10. Shweta D'souza 3 June 2013 at 8:08 pm Reply

    They look so delicious!

    I posted an article on different types of cakes. Why not choose your favorite cake? 😉

  11. lemongrovecakediaries 3 June 2013 at 9:14 pm Reply

    I thought after the last brioche challenge that it would be a while before I would want to make it again but that sounds so delicious I just can’t help myself – now I just have to break the news to my mixer 🙂

  12. Yvonne @ bitter baker 4 June 2013 at 4:16 am Reply

    Yum!! I want a brioche like this! Looks insanely good.

  13. Anne ~ Uni Homemaker 4 June 2013 at 5:03 pm Reply

    Butter brioche sounds fabulous. I would like to sink my teeth into it. 😉 Lovely post…

  14. The Global Garnish Geek 6 June 2013 at 12:30 am Reply

    These look absolutely gorgeous. I just love brioche but haven’t made it in a long time. I think you have inspired me!

  15. Searching For Sugar Plums 12 June 2013 at 11:32 am Reply

    Mmmm I love brioche, and hope to attempt it soon. Thanks for this great post.

  16. paula 19 November 2013 at 5:12 am Reply

    I did the recipe using King Arthur Bread Flour + Farm Eggs + Kerrygold Butter for the main ingredients using my Kitchenaid mixer + hook. Did the measurements using a digital scale. The gluten formed during the first mixing (after 15 minutes) and had a hard time incorporating the butter in it (mixer just kept mushing the room temp butter into the dough so I tore up the dough and added a tbsp of bread flour to help the hook get a grip on the dough. The dough ended up being very sticky and butter-laden. It smells great but there’s no way the dough was ever going to rise (left it to rise for two hours with no progress on the yeast). Left it overnight to rise as well….Nothing. Do you have any clue why?

  17. bricimino 21 January 2014 at 3:04 am Reply

    Brioche is my favorite act of baking voodoo and tedium. Its always so worth it. You seem to have nailed it. You’re brioche is lovely!

    • saucygander 26 January 2014 at 3:16 am Reply

      Thank you! I was really glad it worked out, and the taste was simply amazing, light yet so, so rich at the same time. I like your description of making brioche as baking voodoo!

  18. kurtino 7 March 2016 at 9:59 pm Reply

    A 100% butter brioche dough finished off with a little more yolks, chilled over night then rolled out, cut to desired shapes, allowed to rise at room temp, then deep fried makes the most outstanding beignets!

Penny for your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: